How is the safety of bicycle helmets verified, and what requirements does the European standard EN 1078 impose on them? Our colleague Lukáš Blaha, B.A., from the Engineering Testing Institute answered these questions for Cyklistika magazine. The interview provides insight into the helmet testing process, explains the principles of laboratory testing, and opens a technical discussion on the future development of requirements for cyclists’ head protection.
“The correct and full designation of the standard is ČSN EN 1078+A1:2013 (hereinafter referred to as ČSN EN 1078), and this standard specifies test procedures for verifying the mandatory characteristics of helmets, their design, and labeling. The materials are tested, and the design, field of vision, impact absorption capacity, chin strap, and similar features are verified.”
“Myths must be debunked. It may be commonly believed that impact is absorbed through fracturing, but that is not the case. The ČSN EN 1078 standard is unequivocal: After impact absorption tests, the helmet must not exhibit any damage that could cause serious injury to the user (sharp edges, protrusions). This statement should definitively dispel the myth.”
“The standard specifies that the test laboratory selects the helmet’s impact area on the test surface to represent the worst-case scenario. Tests are conducted for frontal and side impacts, as well as for an impact against a sharp edge simulating a curb, because statistics show that these are the most common types of falls among cyclists in everyday use. When testing impact absorption—in which a helmet with a dummy is dropped from a height onto a metal base—the maximum permissible overload transmitted to the head is 250 g, where “g” represents gravitational acceleration.”
“I’d like to point out that defects are extremely rare. So when a helmet fails a test, it’s usually because of insufficient impact absorption.”
Which is absolutely essential for a helmet’s protective function. Yet, according to the standard, helmets are tested for impacts at a speed of only 19.5 km/h.
“I’d just like to add that helmets are tested for impact resistance not only at a speed of 19.5 km/h (5.42 m/s) against a flat impact pad, but also at a speed of 16.452 km/h (4.57 m/s) against a curb-simulation impact pad. I am bound by the test procedures specified in the standard, and unfortunately, I did not have the opportunity to test helmets for their impact absorption capabilities at higher speeds. It is also important to note that laboratory tests represent a standardized and repeatable method of verifying safety. Real-world accidents tend to be significantly more complex, and their course is influenced by a number of factors, such as the angle of impact, the surface, the obstacle, or the rider’s position. Therefore, a direct conversion between the test speed and the actual riding speed is not possible.”
“Most of the tested samples fall within the upper half of the tested range. It is therefore possible that they could provide protection in the event of a fall at higher speeds. Unfortunately, however, I do not have the exact values available.”
“It was updated in May 2013. Nevertheless, we see that the development of sports equipment and cycling itself is progressing very rapidly. It is therefore natural for experts to review whether the existing requirements correspond to current conditions of use. The mechanism for revising standards specifically accounts for this possibility.”
“There are several such institutions across Europe, and it is usually at their initiative. In our country, it is the Institute for Technical Standardization, Metrology, and State Testing; in Europe, it is the European Committee for Standardization, as well as the Occupational Safety Research Institute and other institutions.”
“As a testing technician, I am required to conduct tests in accordance with the current standard; assessing how the legislation is structured is not within my purview. However, I believe that, in general, stricter rules should apply to head protection equipment used in elite sports. The testing procedure and methodology should follow the relevant standard for the helmet’s intended use (cycling, skiing, water sports, etc.), but with additional requirements for durability. That is merely my personal opinion. At the same time, it’s important to note that the requirements for a racing helmet aren’t just a matter of maximum protection. Manufacturers must strike a balance between safety, weight, ventilation, aerodynamics, and comfort—parameters that are particularly important in professional sports.”
“Personally, I think this is a topic for expert discussion. The current standard sets minimum safety requirements for a broad group of users, ranging from recreational cyclists to athletes. Furthermore, it does not distinguish between individual cycling disciplines, such as road bikes, mountain bikes, or BMX. It sets uniform minimum requirements for helmets intended for cyclists and other specified users. From a testing laboratory’s perspective, this makes sense, as the standard is meant to ensure a basic level of protection for a broad group of users. On the other hand, it is debatable whether the differing conditions of individual disciplines are sufficiently reflected in the head protection requirements. For example, the risks involved in recreational city riding are not entirely the same as those in a top-level road race or off-road downhill riding. This is one reason why the question of potentially refining the requirements should be revisited from time to time in expert discussions. Professional cycling has evolved significantly over the past decade, both in terms of speed and the nature of racing and the equipment used. It is therefore worth considering whether additional requirements or a separate helmet classification should be defined for high-performance or specialized disciplines, similar to what exists in some other sports. However, such a change would have to be based on detailed analyses of actual accidents, medical findings, and manufacturers’ technical capabilities. It is certainly not an issue that can be assessed solely on the basis of laboratory tests.”
We would like to thank the editorial staff of iVelo magazine for dedicating space to the topic of bicycle helmet safety and the work of testing laboratories. We appreciate the opportunity to explain the principles of protective equipment testing and the requirements of the EN 1078 standard to both the professional community and the cycling public.
You can download the full interview with Lukáš Blaha, B.A., here.
The SZÚ Team